In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of credit card fees and scrutinize the recent agreement between the federal government, Visa, and Mastercard. The deal, aimed at reducing interchange fees, has sparked both optimism and skepticism among small business advocates. Let’s unravel the details and assess if the proposed changes truly address the concerns raised by retailers.
DOWNLOAD THE CREDIT CARD FEES INFOGRAPHIC HERE
The Challenge of Credit Card Fees
The heart of the matter lies in the interchange fee, commonly known as the “swipe fee,” which allocates a portion of each transaction to credit card companies and issuing banks. Previously ranging from fractions to over two percent, these fees have posed a significant financial burden, particularly for small businesses. According to Dan Kelly, CEO of the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses (CFIB), Canada bears some of the world’s highest interchange fees, totaling billions annually. ¹
The Recent Agreement
While the new deal promises a reduction in the average interchange fee from 1.4 percent to 0.95 percent for in-store transactions, critics argue that it falls short of providing substantial relief for small businesses. ² Sara Jameson, a Toronto-based small business owner, emphasizes that many struggling businesses won’t qualify for the benefits, limiting the impact on overall economic well-being. The Convenience Industry Council of Canada (CICC) echoes these sentiments, stating that the revenue caps in the agreement exclude many of its members from realizing significant reductions. ³
Voices of Dissent
The discontent extends beyond small businesses, with the CICC asserting that the proposed deal caters more to banks and credit card companies than to local businesses. The group criticizes the revenue caps, arguing that the savings, capped at $1,080 annually, represent a meager sum that will make a limited difference. The dissatisfaction is palpable, as businesses contend with monthly transaction fees that can soar into the thousands, adversely affecting competitiveness against larger corporations.
Longstanding Disputes and Delayed Relief
The genesis of this week’s agreement traces back to a decade-long legal battle led by the CFIB, reaching its initial resolution last fall. Although the updated rules now allow merchants to pass interchange fees directly to consumers, the anticipated benefits of the new fee deal won’t materialize until fall 2024. Despite the delay, Dan Kelly remains optimistic, emphasizing the long-term advantages for both small businesses and consumers.
The recent deal to lower Visa and Mastercard processing fees may not be the panacea small businesses had hoped for. As the implementation is scheduled for fall 2024, immediate relief remains elusive. The discontent expressed by small business owners and industry groups underscores the need for a more comprehensive solution. In navigating the landscape of credit card fees, businesses may need to explore alternatives such as the NextGen Payment Solutions (NPS) Canada to gauge customer satisfaction and loyalty, ultimately influencing their pricing strategies.
Footnotes:
- “Deal to lower Visa, Mastercard processing fees will come up short for many retailers, critics say”,
- “Government of Canada announces finalized agreements with Visa and Mastercard to lower credit card transaction fees for small businesses”, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, December 05, 2023. Cision
- “Government announces lower credit card transaction fees for small businesses”, Department of Finance Canada. May 18, 2023. Department of Finance Canada